One of the most important pieces of VST e-drummer equipment: suitable headphones and a headphone amplifier 👉
#1
One of the most important pieces of VST e-drummer equipment: suitable headphones and a headphone amplifier 👉
What features should the headphones have :
1. They should seal well so that the sounds of the pad strikes don’t reach our ears.
2. Such closed-back headphones should also sound enjoyable (and ideally not drastically distort the frequency response—which can be a real challenge with closed-back systems!) and shouldn’t distort when handling high-power signals (e.g., bass-heavy drums like floor toms at high volumes).
3. It shouldn't feel like an intake socket when it comes to insulation, and it should be comfortable to wear overall.
4. The cable should be connectable to one side only, and it shouldn't be shorter than 3 meters—and, of course, it shouldn't be a coiled cable, and the weight should be light and thin. If a pair of headphones doesn't come with a cable like that, I'll replace it if possible.
There are many manufacturers and models that label themselves as “closed-back” on the packaging, but the differences in sound isolation can still be quite significant.
Of course, good in-ear monitors (IEMs) can also replace closed-back headphones; they usually provide very good sound isolation, but they aren't for everyone (comfort/fit).
What features should a headphone amplifier have :
It should be analog, have balanced inputs, deliver sufficient power, and sound neutral—or even musically enhancing. You can completely rule out any kind of cheap devices; the amp should provide a better listening experience than the headphone jack on the audio interface.
The headphone outputs of audio interfaces can't match the sound quality achieved when using a high-quality headphone amplifier (connected to the line outputs of the audio interface). My recommendation for enjoying drum sounds when playing e-drums (and with the superb sounds from good drum samplers and DAW projects, we VST e-drummers are, after all, able to get the crème de la crème out of e-drum sound: which, in my opinion, deserves to reach your ears through the best sound transducers (and the HP amp is definitely a part of the sound transducers) is definitely to use a device like this (I use Lake People headphone amps). The line-out sound of the best value-for-money winner, the MOTU M2, or an RME device connected via balanced cables to a Lake People G111, is definitely top-notch: the definitive ticket to e-drum heaven 😊.
Tweaking the headphone sound by DSP effects :
I also recommend (and almost always use) good headphone sound enhancement plugins like “Sonarworks”, “ToneBoosters Morphit”, and “MathAudio Headphone EQ”, and of course the good old “FabFilter ProQ”. With this arsenal of tools, you can achieve your dream sound and possibly even smooth out the uneven frequency response of closed-back headphones (I often use a combination of two or three of the tools mentioned and usually set a relatively low Wet/Dry value for Sonarworks and Morphit).
IMO suitable headphone models :
∙ Sennheiser HD-480 PRO
∙ Sennheiser HD-620S
∙ AKG K-872
∙ AKG K-271
I can confirm that Sennheiser Hd480 pro are certainly right now the best over ear headphones out there for E-Drumming!
Since I use closed back headphones for E-Drumming) for almost 12 years I tried almost all brands.
What makes these 480pro so good:
1.
Comfort (sure it has to fit your head size!)
The weight distribution, weight and pads are the best I encountered, i.e. even the second best comfortable Austrian Audio Hi-x 60, are not as light on the head, the headband of the Hd480pro does not even touch the top of my head, superb! Sennheisers 620s has a little better isolation, but 480pro is not far behind.
The fabric of the cup which contacts ears is even more comfortable and non sweaty than Sure alcantara pads. I experienced hottest day in history of Germany last week, what can I say.....it worked....
Please check this list for further information in terms of comfort, cable and weight, driver type
#3
Sennheiser headphone cables :
If 1.8m is too short for you (it is for me!): There’s a 3m straight cable available for the HD-480 Pro. 🙂
There is also a 3m straight cable that fits the HD-620S: the Sennheiser “572266” cable 🙂
...By the way, AKG is always exemplary when it comes to the included 3 meter straight cables. 🙂
2. Sound
In terms of sound there is IMHO no contest, only Sennheiser HD480 are able to deliver a natural, realistic and punchy sound, which features really deep bass, quite good natural mids, agreeable (a little soft and not much extended) treble, they are not congested, not annoying honky and weird in the mids which almost all closed headphones are.
Cheaper Sennheiser 620s are also ok and recomended, but lack subs, treble is a bit harsh, they are also less direct and thinner in the mids/sub bass and more distant sounding.
Focal Azurys lack good secure fit and isolation, mids are less congested than Radiance, but very simlar. I like both Sennheisers way way more.
Sure the bass of very expensive and heavier and absolute best isolating AKG 872 and Focal Radiance (to a much lesser degree only in terms of punch) is more solid, clear, detailed, analytical and punchier (Focal)....but the AKG/Focal core sound does not sound natural, the mids are a always weird...treble nothing special on Focals a little metallic and both are imho much more annoying for long term use.
Only DCA E3 (2500 Euro) are a touch more natural and 3d sounding (trait of planar) and feature better best treble (in terms of closed back), but they are not punchy mid centric, beefy E-drum headphones, they are heavy, isolation is almost not existant.....you have to eq a lot iof upper bass and mids, which is extremely difficult and depends on special expensive headphone amps or latest RME hp outputs...a pain in the a.........otherwise not loud enough.
Punch still lacks a bit with DCA headphones....they are very neutral, most resolving and calm though, for simple listening best closed heaphones I know, I add more mids, upper bass and a slight high shelf with eq.
Denon and Fostex (isolation is meh) line is quite open, non congested sounding, but also thin in the mids and upper bass....treble is extended but somehow weird.....imho if you like Beyerdynamics (harsh treble peak, distant sounding, weak bass, reduced mids) Fostex and Denon are better versions of this sound profile.....I do not like this big stage and distant performance....I like player perspective of Hd480 pro, 620s, Focal line and AKG way more.
You might ask, "hey, why are no closed and very expensive Hifiman Audivina, closed Sennheiser Hd820, closed Focal Stellia included in my test, review?
These headphones models should be flagships of their line/brand.
I have tried them side by side with my Focal Radiance/HD620 and very good open (again no e-drum) Hifiman 10000se/Austrian Audio Composer (both imho show what is possible today in terms of dynamic and planar driver open design) at my local dealer.
Result:
Audivina, Hd820, Stellia are all horrible, considering their price even ridiculous.
The mids and even (sub)bass (on HD820, Audivina) are horrible, they sacrificed a good frequency response for a bigger stage more depth.
Reason:
In the Hifi world a lot of people swear by deep stage, holographic 3dness, audience perspective....the legendary (not usable for e-drums open Sennheiser Hd800) delivers this in spades.....but they lack a lot of bass and have on several heads in quite brutal lower treble. You are in a kind of soundcloud, very airy.
IMHO different brands (Focal, Sennheiser, Hifiman) tried to implement this sound behavior into an already (always!!!) inherent problematic closed headphone design at all costs. i.e. further weakening the frequency response.
For this reason in terms of frequency response these expensive flagship models fail, i.e. especially in the mids, which are the most important requency to gain a natural perception
Audivina perception:
https://youtu.be/0QBQtshJ2Qo?t=3920
HD 820 perception:
https://youtu.be/0QBQtshJ2Qo?t=5201
Focal Stellia (the best of these three) Radiance is better (although technically not as advanced)
https://youtu.be/0QBQtshJ2Qo?t=2868
So, why including them, does make no sense.
The importance of mids, reason Hd480pro are so good (similarity to open Sennheiser Hd600, not usable for E-drums open design headphone)
Very good video, I have also a very similar perception, not in terms of Audeze!
His thesis (this is a mastering perspective, he is focusing strongly on mids, natural performance) he is neglecting bass performance a lot.
https://youtu.be/PkEseNXzBLw?t=249
Hd480 was not released, he has also not heard Hd620 also quite new.....
We will see......
- Hello VST e-drummers
- Introductions & forum rules & announcements
- Your VST-e-drum covers / VST-e-drum performance videos
- NEWS
- Main Forum
- e-drum hardware , computer , audio interface , headphones ( & HP amps...
- Software Drumming Engines / FIXES and support
- important VST e-drum Fixes
- Presentation of single VST e-drum engines / fixes and subsequent discu...
- SNARE --- engines / fixes
- HIHAT --- engines / fixes
- KICK (Bass Drum) --- engines
- CYMBAL --- engines / fixes
- TOM --- engines / fixes
- Superior Drummer
- EZ Drummer
- GGD (GetGood Drums)
- MixWave
- NI Studio Drummmer + Abbey Road Drummer
- other KONTAKT libraries
- Steven Slate Drums ∙ ( SSD5.5 )
- Groove Agent libraries (like 'Simon Phillips Studio Drums')
- BFD , BFD Player , Addictive Drums 2
- other drum samplers / (drum) instruments
- Ableton Live -- Cymbal Choking
- LIVE Software Drumming + Toggle VST-e-drum functions/engines during a ...
- Software Drumming Support
- Tips & Tricks
- Software recommendations
- SPECIALS / Special Engines
- Software Drumming Lighting Engines
- discussing and reviewing drum samplers (and DAWs for e-drumming)
- Forum member Threads
- Guest Threads
- FEATURE REQUESTs ∙ (e-drum hardware + module/trigger device + software)
- Specialist media / trade press and content of specialist retailers and...
- deutsches VST-eDrum-Forum
Register now!
Sign up now!
